MY RTI JUDGEMENTS: September 2016

RTI. No.GSIC/US/PIO/RTI/2014/

Office of State Information Commission,

Shrama Shakti Bhavan,

Ground Floor, Panaji, Goa.

Dated : 16/06/2014.

Contact : 2437208 / 7507030022.

To,

Shri. Romen Gohain

R/o. Lachit Nagar, Khubalia,

Dhemaji, Assam. 787057.

Contact No : 09401954862.

Subject : Information under Right to Information Act, 2005.

Reference : 1. Your letter No. RG/DMJ/RTI/2013-14/1012, dated 12/05/2014.

2. Your letter dated 03/06/2014 ( Inward/Entry dated 10/06/2014).

With reference to your RTI application dated 12/05/2014 (Inward/Entry dated 21/05/2014) on the subject cited above, you had requested for three Annual Reports of Goa State Information Commission for the years 2006-2007; 2007-2008; and 2008-2009, however, as per your subsequent letter dated 03/06/2014 ( Inward/Entry dated 10/06/2014) pertaining to fees paid, you have stated that you want only one Annual Report for the year 2006-2007 and you have paid fees for the said one Annual Report 2006-2007 only.

In view of above, find enclosed herewith the Annual Report 2006-2007 of the Goa State Information Commission as requested by you.

{ Siddhi T. Halarnakar)

Under Secretary / PIO,

Goa State Information Commission.

----------------------------------------------------------

RTI. No.GSIC/US/PIO/RTI/2014/

Office of State Information Commission,

Shrama Shakti Bhavan,

Ground Floor, Panaji, Goa.

Dated : 23/05/2014.

Contact : 2437208 / 7507030022.

To,

Shri. Romen Gohain

R/o. Lachit Nagar, Khubalia,

Dhemaji, Assam. 787057.

Contact No : 09401954862.

Subject : Information under Right to Information Act, 2005.

Reference : Your letter No. RG/DMJ/RTI/2013-14/1012, dated 12/05/2014.

With reference to your RTI application dated 12/05/2014 (Inward/Entry dated 21/05/2014) on the subject cited above, I am to inform you that the information sought by you asking for copies of the annual reports of Goa State Information Commission on diskette for the years of 2006-07, 2007-2008, and 2008-09 is available only in Hard copy and the same will be provided by this office on payment of the fees which are as follows :

Sr. No.	Annual Report.	Number of pages.	Amount of fees ( in rupees).
1.	Annual Report 2006-2007 of Goa State Information Commission in hard copy form.	97	194
2	Annual Report 2007-2008 of Goa State Information Commission in hard copy form.	228	456
3	Annual Report 2008-2009 of Goa State Information Commission in hard copy form..	235	470
	TOTAL :	560	Rs.1120/-

{ Siddhi T. Halarnakar)

Under Secretary / PIO,

Goa State Information Commission.

--------------------------------------------------

RTI. No.GSIC/US/PIO/RTI/2014/

Registered AD Post. Office of State Information Commission,

Shrama Shakti Bhavan,

Ground Floor, Panaji, Goa.

Dated : 04/06/2014.

Contact : 2437208.

To,

Shri. Ashok Dessai,

R/o. 309, 3^rd floor, Damodar Phase II’ Near Police Station,

Margao, Salcete, Goa.

Subject : Information under Right to Information Act, 2005.

With reference to your RTI application dated 09/05/2014 (Inward/Entry dated 09/05/2014) on the subject cited above, I am to inform you that the information sought by you asking for copies of the proceeding sheets (Roznama) and Order of the following complaint case is ready and the same be collected from this office on payment of the fees which are as follows :

Question No.	Question.	Number of pages.	Amount of fees (in rupees.)
1.	Proceeding sheet / Roznama of Complaint No.57/SIC/2011 from the beginning till the final disposal of the complaint.	08	16
2	Order made in this Complaint No. 57/SIC/2011 on 07/04/2014.	05	10
	Total :	13	26

{ Siddhi T. Halarnakar)

Under Secretary / PIO,

Goa State Information Commission.

470

TOTAL :

560

Rs.1120/-

{ Siddhi T. Halarnakar)

Under Secretary / PIO,

Goa State Information Commission.

----------------------------------------------

RTI. No.GSIC/US/PIO/RTI/2014/

Office of State Information Commission,

Shrama Shakti Bhavan,

Ground Floor, Panaji, Goa.

Dated : 19/05/2014.

Contact : 2437208.

To,

Shri. Ashok Dessai,

R/o. 309, 3^rd floor, Damodar Phase II’ Near Police Station,

Margao, Salcete, Goa.

Subject : Information under Right to Information Act, 2005.

With reference to your RTI application dated 24/04/2014 (Inward/Entry dated 25/04/2014) on the subject cited above, I am to inform you that the information sought by you asking for certified copies of the proceeding sheets (Roznama) and Orders of the following complaint cases is ready and the same be collected from this office on payment of the fees which are as follows :

Question No.	Question.	Number of pages.	Amount of fees (in rupees.)
1.	Certified copies of proceeding sheet/ Roznama of complaint No.90/SCIC/2013 from beginning till 28/11/2013.	02	04
2	Certified copies of Order made on 28/11/2013 by the Hon’ble SCIC disposing the complaint No.90/SCIC/2013.	03	06
3	Certified copies of proceeding sheet/Roznama of complaint No.39/SIC/2013 from beginning till 06/02/2014.	02	04
5	Certified copies of proceeding sheet/Roznama of complaint No.37/SIC/2013 from beginning till 06/02/2014.	02	04
7	Certified copies of proceeding sheet/Roznama of complaint No.40/SCIC/2013 from beginning till 06/02/2014.	03	06
9	Certified copies of proceeding sheet/Roznama of complaint No.38/SIC/2013 from beginning till 06/02/2014.	02	04
4,6,8, and 10.	Certified copies of Common Order made on 06/02/2014 by the Hon’ble SCIC disposing the complaints No.39/SIC/2013 ; 37/SIC/2013 ; 40/SCIC/2013 ; and 38/SCIC/2013.	02	04
	Total :	16	32

{ Siddhi T. Halarnakar)

Under Secretary / PIO,

Goa State Information Commission.

----------------------------------------------------------

RTI. No.GSIC/US/PIO/RTI/2014/

Office of State Information Commission,

Shrama Shakti Bhavan,

Ground Floor, Panaji, Goa.

Dated : 31/05/2014.

Contact : 2437208.

To,

Shri. Ashok Dessai,

R/o. 309, 3^rd floor, Damodar Phase II’ Near Police Station,

Margao, Salcete, Goa.

Subject : Information under Right to Information Act, 2005.

With reference to your RTI application dated 09/05/2014 on the subject cited above, find enclosed herewith the copies of the proceeding sheets (Roznama) and Order in Complaint case No.57/SIC/2011 as required by you, the details of which are as follows :

Sr. No.	Question.	Reply.	Number of pages.
1.	Proceeding sheet / Roznama of complaint No.57/SIC/2011 from the beginning till the final disposal of the complaint.
2	Order made in the Complaint No.57/SIC/2011 on 07/04/2014.
		TOTAL :

{ Siddhi T. Halarnakar)

Under Secretary / PIO,

---------------------------------------------------------

RTI. No.GSIC/US/PIO/RTI/2014/

Registered AD Post. Office of State Information Commission,

Shrama Shakti Bhavan,

Ground Floor, Panaji, Goa.

Dated : 04/06/2014.

Contact : 2437208.

To,

Shri. Ashok Dessai,

R/o. 309, 3^rd floor, Damodar Phase II’ Near Police Station,

Margao, Salcete, Goa.

Subject : Information under Right to Information Act, 2005.

With reference to your RTI application dated 09/05/2014 (Inward/Entry dated 09/05/2014) on the subject cited above, I am to inform you that the information in Question No.1, 2, and 4 sought by you is as follows :

Sr. No.	Question.	Reply.
1.	Inform date, month, and year when Ms. Leena Mehandale took over the charge of Goa State Chief Information Commissioner.	24/10/2013
2	Inform the number of Complaints under section 18 she disposed till 30/04/2014.	32
4	Inform the number of Appeals under section 19(3) RTI Act, 2005 she disposed till 30-4-2014..	41

As regards your Question No.3 and 5 the copies of the Orders in the disposed Complaint cases and disposed Appeal cases during the period from 24/10/2013 to 30/04/2014 by the Goa State Chief Information Commissioner, we have recently began the process of uploading the same on the Commission’s website www.goasic.gov.in and you can download them as and when uploaded but latest by 31^st July, 2014.

However, if you require a hard copy of these said Orders, then the Orders which are typed and ready will be provided to you on payment of the fees; and where the Orders are not typed, the copies of Roznama Orders will be provided. All this requires payment of the following fees :

Question No.	Question.	Number of pages.	Amount of fees (in rupees.)
3	Provide the orders made by her in EACH disposed complaint under section 18 RTI Act, 2005.	84	168
5	Provide the orders made by her in EACH disposed appeals under section 19(3) RTI Act, 2005.	84	168

The above number of pages and amount of fees is an approximate figure and the same may vary by another 10%.

{ Siddhi T. Halarnakar)

Under Secretary / PIO,

Goa State Information Commission.

RTI. No.GSIC/US/PIO/RTI/2014/

Office of State Information Commission,

Shrama Shakti Bhavan,

Ground Floor, Panaji, Goa.

Dated : 04/06/2014.

Contact : 2437208.

To,

Shri. Ashok Dessai,

R/o. 309, 3^rd floor, Damodar Phase II’ Near Police Station,

Margao, Salcete, Goa.

Subject : Information under Right to Information Act, 2005.

With reference to your RTI application dated 09/05/2014 on the subject cited above, find enclosed herewith the information sought by you about the disposed complaint and appeal cases during the period from 24/10/2013 to 30/04/2014 as required by you.

Sr. No.	Question.	Reply.	Number of pages.
1.	Inform date, month, and year when Ms. Leena Mehandale took over the charge of Goa State Chief Information Commissioner.
2	Inform the number of complaints under section 18 she disposed till 30/04/2014.
3	Provide the orders made by her in EACH disposed complaint under section 18 RTI Act, 2005.	Annexure A.
4	Inform the number of appeals under section 19(3) RTI Act, 2005 she disposed till 30-4-2014..
5	Provide the orders made by her in EACH disposed appeals under section 19(3) RTI Act, 2005.	Annexure B.
		TOTAL :

{ Siddhi T. Halarnakar)

Under Secretary / PIO,

RTI. No.GSIC/US/PIO/RTI/2014/

Office of State Information Commission,

Shrama Shakti Bhavan,

Ground Floor, Panaji, Goa.

Dated : 20/05/2014.

Contact : 2437208.

To,

Shri. Ashok Dessai,

R/o. 309, 3^rd floor, Damodar Phase II’ Near Police Station,

Margao, Salcete, Goa.

Subject : Information under Right to Information Act, 2005.

With reference to your RTI application dated 25/04/2014 on the subject cited above, find enclosed herewith the attested copies of the proceeding sheets (Roznama) and Orders of the following RTI Complaint cases as required by you, the details of which are as follows :

Question No.	Question.	Number of pages.
1.	Certified copies of proceeding sheet/ Roznama of complaint No.90/SCIC/2013 from beginning till 28/11/2013.	02
2	Certified copies of Order made on 28/11/2013 by the Hon’ble SCIC disposing the complaint No.90/SCIC/2013.	03
3	Certified copies of proceeding sheet/Roznama of complaint No.39/SIC/2013 from beginning till 06/02/2014.	02
5	Certified copies of proceeding sheet/Roznama of complaint No.37/SIC/2013 from beginning till 06/02/2014.	02
7	Certified copies of proceeding sheet/Roznama of complaint No.40/SCIC/2013 from beginning till 06/02/2014.	03
9	Certified copies of proceeding sheet/Roznama of complaint No.38/SIC/2013 from beginning till 06/02/2014.	02
4,6,8, and 10.	Certified copies of Common Order made on 06/02/2014 by the Hon’ble SCIC disposing the complaints No.39/SIC/2013 ; 37/SIC/2013 ; 40/SCIC/2013 ; and 38/SCIC/2013.	02
	Total :	16

{ Siddhi T. Halarnakar)

Under Secretary / PIO,

Goa State Information Commission.

---------------------------------------------

RTI. No.GSIC/US/PIO/RTI/2014/

Office of State Information Commission,

Shrama Shakti Bhavan,

Ground Floor, Panaji, Goa.

Dated : 31/05/2014.

Contact : 2437208.

To,

Shri. Ashok Dessai,

R/o. 309, 3^rd floor, Damodar Phase II’ Near Police Station,

Margao, Salcete, Goa.

Subject : Information under Right to Information Act, 2005.

With reference to your RTI application dated 09/05/2014 (Inward/Entry dated 09/05/2014) on the subject cited above, I am to inform you that the information sought by you pertaining to Complaint No.57/SIC/2011, be collected from this office on payment of the fees of Rs……… /- @ Rs.2/- per page.

{ Siddhi T. Halarnakar)

Under Secretary / PIO,

Goa State Information Commission.

RTI. No.GSIC/US/PIO/RTI/2014/

Office of State Information Commission,

Shrama Shakti Bhavan,

Ground Floor, Panaji, Goa.

Dated : 31/05/2014.

Contact : 2437208.

To,

Shri. Ashok Dessai,

R/o. 309, 3^rd floor, Damodar Phase II’ Near Police Station,

Margao, Salcete, Goa.

Subject : Information under Right to Information Act, 2005.

With reference to your RTI application dated 09/05/2014 (Inward/Entry dated 09/05/2014) on the subject cited above, I am to inform you that the information sought by you about the disposed complaint and appeal cases during the period from 24/10/2013 to 30/04/2014 be collected from this office on payment of the fees of Rs. …… /- @ of Rs.2/- per page.

{ Siddhi T. Halarnakar)

Under Secretary / PIO,

Goa State Information Commission.

RTI. No.GSIC/US/PIO/RTI/2014/

Office of State Information Commission,

Shrama Shakti Bhavan,

Ground Floor, Panaji, Goa.

Dated : 31/05/2014.

Contact : 2437208.

To,

Shri. Ashok Dessai,

R/o. 309, 3^rd floor, Damodar Phase II’ Near Police Station,

Margao, Salcete, Goa.

Subject : Information under Right to Information Act, 2005.

Sr. No.	Question.	Reply.	Number of pages.
1.	Inform date, month, and year when Ms. Leena Mehandale took over the charge of Goa State Chief Information Commissioner.
2	Inform the number of complaints under section 18 she disposed till 30/04/2014.
3	Provide the orders made by her in EACH disposed complaint under section 18 RTI Act, 2005.	Annexure A.
4	Inform the number of appeals under section 19(3) RTI Act, 2005 she disposed till 30-4-2014..
5	Provide the orders made by her in EACH disposed appeals under section 19(3) RTI Act, 2005.	Annexure B.
		TOTAL :

{ Siddhi T. Halarnakar)

Under Secretary / PIO,

==================================

RTI. No.GSIC/US/PIO/RTI/2014/

Office of State Information Commission,

Shrama Shakti Bhavan,

Ground Floor, Panaji, Goa.

Dated : 20/05/2014.

Contact : 2437208.

To,

Shri. Ashok Dessai,

R/o. 309, 3^rd floor, Damodar Phase II, Near Police Station,

Margao, Salcete, Goa.

Subject : Information under Right to Information Act, 2005.

With reference to your RTI application dated 25/04/2014 on the subject cited above, find enclosed herewith the attested copies of the proceeding sheets (Roznama) of the following RTI Complaint cases as required by you, the details of which are as follows :

Serial No.	Complaint case No.	Number of pages.
1.	28/SIC/2012	4
2	29/SIC/2012	4
3	186/SIC/2011	4
4	187/SIC/2011	4
5	188/SIC/2011	4
6	189/SIC/2011	4
7	190/SIC/2011	4
8	191/SIC/2011	4
9	192/SIC/2011	4
10	193/SIC/2011	4
11	194/SIC/2011	4
12	195/SIC/2011	4
13	196/SIC/2011	4
14	197/SIC/2011	4

Contd ….. 2/-

- 2 -

Serial No.	Complaint case No.	Number of pages.
15.	11/SIC/2013	2
16	12/SIC/2013	2
17	27/SIC/2013	1
18	28/SIC/2013	1
19	40/SIC/2012	4
20	41/SIC/2012	4
21	15/SIC/2013	2
22	16/SIC/2013	2
23	17/SIC/2013	2
24	21/SIC/2013	2
25	22/SIC/2013	2
26	23/SIC/2013	2
27	563/SIC/2010	5
28	151/SIC/2012	2
29	59/SIC/2012	4
	Total :	93

( Siddhi T. Halarnakar)

Under Secretary / PIO,

Goa State Information Commission.

Enclosed : As above.

RTI. No.GSIC/US/PIO/RTI/2014/

Office of State Information Commission,

Shrama Shakti Bhavan,

Ground Floor, Panaji, Goa.

Dated : 20/05/2014.

Contact : 2437208.

To,

Shri. Ashok Dessai,

R/o. 309, 3^rd floor, Damodar Phase II’ Near Police Station,

Margao, Salcete, Goa.

Subject : Information under Right to Information Act, 2005.

Serial No.	Complaint case No.	Number of pages.
1.	168/SCIC/2011	5
2	38/SCIC/2012	3
3	39/SCIC/2012	3
4	57/SCIC/2012	5
5	55/SCIC/2012	5
6	56/SCIC/2012	4
7	95/SCIC/2013	1
8	198/SCIC/2011	4
9	199/SCIC/2011	4
10	200/SCIC/2011	4
11	201/SCIC/2011	4
12	202/SCIC/2011	4
13	203/SCIC/2011	4
14	204/SCIC/2011	4

Contd ….. 2/-

- 2 -

Serial No.	Complaint case No.	Number of pages.
15.	205/SCIC/2011	4
16	206/SCIC/2011	4
17	207/SCIC/2011	4
18	208/SCIC/2011	4
19	209/SCIC/2011	4
20	62/SCIC/2013	2
21	29/SCIC/2013	2
22	90/SCIC/2012	4
23	125/SCIC/2013	1
24	85/SIC/2013	1
25	87/SIC/2013	1
26	89/SIC/2013	1
	Total :	86

( Siddhi T. Halarnakar)

Under Secretary / PIO,

Goa State Information Commission.

---------------------------------------------------------

RTI. No.GSIC/US/PIO/RTI/2014/

Office of State Information Commission,

Shrama Shakti Bhavan,

Ground Floor, Panaji, Goa.

Dated : 14/05/2014.

Contact : 2437208.

To,

Shri. Ashok Dessai,

R/o. 309, 3^rd floor, Damodar Phase II’ Near Police Station,

Margao, Salcete, Goa.

Subject : Information under Right to Information Act, 2005.

With reference to your RTI application dated 09/05/2014 (Inward/Entry dated 09/05/2014) on the subject cited above, I am to inform you that the information sought by you asking for copies of the Orders of the following complaint and appeal cases is ready and the same be collected from this office on payment of the fees which are as follows :

Sr. No.	Question.	Number of pages.	Amount of fees ( in rupees).
1.	Inform date, month, and year when Ms. Leena Mehandale took over the charge of Goa State Chief Information Commissioner.
2	Inform the number of complaints under section 18 she disposed till 30/04/2014.
3	Provide the orders made by her in EACH disposed complaint under section 18 RTI Act, 2005.
4	Inform the number of appeals under section 19(3) RTI Act, 2005 she disposed till 30-4-2014..
5	Provide the orders made by her in EACH disposed appeals under section 19(3) RTI Act, 2005.
		TOTAL :	Rs.

{ Siddhi T. Halarnakar)

Under Secretary / PIO,

Goa State Information Commission.

RTI. No.GSIC/US/PIO/RTI/2014/

Office of State Information Commission,

Shrama Shakti Bhavan,

Ground Floor, Panaji, Goa.

Dated : 14/05/2014.

Contact : 2437208.

To,

Shri. Ashok Dessai,

R/o. 309, 3^rd floor, Damodar Phase II’ Near Police Station,

Margao, Salcete, Goa.

Subject : Information under Right to Information Act, 2005.

With reference to your RTI application dated 09/05/2014 on the subject cited above, find enclosed herewith the attested copies of the proceeding sheets (Roznama) and Order dated ……. of the following RTI Complaint case as required by you, the details of which are as follows :

Serial No.	Question.	Reply	Number of pages.
1.	Proceeding sheet / Roznama of Complaint No.57/SIC/2011 from the beginning till the final disposal of the complaint.
2	57/SIC/2011
	Total :

{ Siddhi T. Halarnakar)

Under Secretary / PIO,

Goa State Information Commission.

RTI. No.GSIC/US/PIO/RTI/2014/

Office of State Information Commission,

Shrama Shakti Bhavan,

Ground Floor, Panaji, Goa.

Dated : 19/05/2014.

Contact : 2437208.

To,

Shri. Ashok Dessai,

R/o. 309, 3^rd floor, Damodar Phase II’ Near Police Station,

Margao, Salcete, Goa.

Subject : Information under Right to Information Act, 2005.

Question No.	Question.	Number of pages.	Amount of fees (in rupees.)
1.	Certified copies of proceeding sheet/ Roznama of complaint No.90/SCIC/2013 from beginning till 28/11/2013.	02	04
2	Certified copies of Order made on 28/11/2013 by the Hon’ble SCIC disposing the complaint No.90/SCIC/2013.	03	06
3	Certified copies of proceeding sheet/Roznama of complaint No.39/SIC/2013 from beginning till 06/02/2014.	02	04
5	Certified copies of proceeding sheet/Roznama of complaint No.37/SIC/2013 from beginning till 06/02/2014.	02	04
7	Certified copies of proceeding sheet/Roznama of complaint No.40/SCIC/2013 from beginning till 06/02/2014.	03	06
9	Certified copies of proceeding sheet/Roznama of complaint No.38/SIC/2013 from beginning till 06/02/2014.	02	04
4,6,8, and 10.	Certified copies of Common Order made on 06/02/2014 by the Hon’ble SCIC disposing the complaints No.39/SIC/2013 ; 37/SIC/2013 ; 40/SCIC/2013 ; and 38/SCIC/2013.	02	04
	Total :	16	32

{ Siddhi T. Halarnakar)

Under Secretary / PIO,

Goa State Information Commission.

RTI. No.GSIC/US/PIO/RTI/2014/

Office of State Information Commission,

Shrama Shakti Bhavan,

Ground Floor, Panaji, Goa.

Dated : 19/05/2014.

Contact : 2437208.

To,

Shri. Ashok Dessai,

R/o. 309, 3^rd floor, Damodar Phase II’ Near Police Station,

Margao, Salcete, Goa.

Subject : Information under Right to Information Act, 2005.

With reference to your RTI application dated 25/04/2014 on the subject cited above, I am to inform you that the information sought by you asking for attested copies of the proceeding sheets (Roznama) of the following complaint cases is ready and the same be collected from this office on payment of the fees which are as follows :

Serial No.	Complaint case No.	Number of pages.	Amount of fees (in rupees.)
1.	168/SCIC/2011	5	10
2	38/SCIC/2012	3	6
3	39/SCIC/2012	3	6
4	57/SCIC/2012	5	10
5	55/SCIC/2012	5	10
6	56/SCIC/2012	4	8
7	95/SCIC/2013	1	2
8	198/SCIC/2011	4	8
9	199/SCIC/2011	4	8
10	200/SCIC/2011	4	8
11	201/SCIC/2011	4	8
12	202/SCIC/2011	4	8
13	203/SCIC/2011	4	8
14	204/SCIC/2011	4	8

Contd ….. 2/-

- 2 -

Serial No.	Complaint case No.	Number of pages.	Amount of fees (in rupees.)
15.	205/SCIC/2011	4	8
16	206/SCIC/2011	4	8
17	207/SCIC/2011	4	8
18	208/SCIC/2011	4	8
19	209/SCIC/2011	4	8
20	62/SCIC/2013	2	4
21	29/SCIC/2013	2	4
22	90/SCIC/2012	4	8
23	125/SCIC/2013	1	2
24	85/SIC/2013	1	2
25	87/SIC/2013	1	2
26	89/SIC/2013	1	2
	Total :	86	172

{ Siddhi T. Halarnakar)

Under Secretary / PIO,

Goa State Information Commission.

=--------------------------------------------------------

RTI. No.GSIC/US/PIO/RTI/2014/

Office of State Information Commission,

Shrama Shakti Bhavan,

Ground Floor, Panaji, Goa.

Dated : 19/05/2014.

Contact : 2437208.

To,

Shri. Ashok Dessai,

R/o. 309, 3^rd floor, Damodar Phase II’ Near Police Station,

Margao, Salcete, Goa.

Subject : Information under Right to Information Act, 2005.

Serial No.	Complaint case No.	Number of pages.	Amount of fees (in rupees.)
1.	28/SIC/2012	4	8
2	29/SIC/2012	4	8
3	186/SIC/2011	4	8
4	187/SIC/2011	4	8
5	188/SIC/2011	4	8
6	189/SIC/2011	4	8
7	190/SIC/2011	4	8
8	191/SIC/2011	4	8
9	192/SIC/2011	4	8
10	193/SIC/2011	4	8
11	194/SIC/2011	4	8
12	195/SIC/2011	4	8
13	196/SIC/2011	4	8
14	197/SIC/2011	4	8

Contd ….. 2/-

- 2 -

Serial No.	Complaint case No.	Number of pages.	Amount of fees (in rupees.)
15.	11/SIC/2013	2	4
16	12/SIC/2013	2	4
17	27/SIC/2013	1	2
18	28/SIC/2013	1	2
19	40/SIC/2012	4	8
20	41/SIC/2012	4	8
21	15/SIC/2013	2	4
22	16/SIC/2013	2	4
23	17/SIC/2013	2	4
24	21/SIC/2013	2	4
25	22/SIC/2013	2	4
26	23/SIC/2013	2	4
27	563/SIC/2010	5	10
28	151/SIC/2012	2	4
29	59/SIC/2012	4	8
	Total :	93	186

{ Siddhi T. Halarnakar)

Under Secretary / PIO,

Goa State Information Commission.

RTI. No.GSIC/US/PIO/RTI/2014/

Office of State Information Commission,

Shrama Shakti Bhavan,

Ground Floor, Panaji, Goa.

Dated : 12/05/2014.

Contact : 2437208.

To,

Mrs. Anjali Bharadwaj,

R/o. B-76, S.F.S Flats (Triveni Apartments),

Sheikh Sarai Phase-I, New Delhi. 110017.

Contact : 011-41018185.

Subject : Information under Right to Information Act, 2005.

Reference : letter No. No.GSIC/US/PIO/RTI/2014/169, dated 09/05/2014 of PIO, GSIC.

With reference to this office letter No. No.GSIC/US/PIO/RTI/2014/169, dated 09/05/2014, I am to inform you that the last para in the said letter be corrected as follows :

“It is requested that the above fees of Rs.20/- (Rupees Twenty only) be paid by way of sticking court fee stamp worth Rs.20/- on a paper addressed to this office”.

It is to be noted that it is wrongly gone as “revenue stamp” instead of ‘court fee stamps”.

{ Siddhi T. Halarnakar)

Under Secretary / PIO,

Goa State Information Commission.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

RTI. No.GSIC/US/PIO/RTI/2014/

Office of State Information Commission,

Shrama Shakti Bhavan,

Ground Floor, Panaji, Goa.

Dated : 09/05/2014.

Contact : 2437208.

To,

Mrs. Anjali Bharadwaj,

R/o. B-76, S.F.S Flats (Triveni Apartments),

Sheikh Sarai Phase-I, New Delhi. 110017.

Contact : 011-41018185.

Subject : Information under Right to Information Act, 2005.

With reference to your RTI application dated 28/04/2014 (Inward/Entry dated 02/05/2014) on the subject cited above, I am to inform you that the information sought by you is ready and the same be collected from this office on payment of the fees which are as follows :

Sr. No.	Question.	Number of pages.	Amount of fees ( in rupees).
1.	Number of Complaints where an inquiry was initiated by the Commission as per the powers vested in it under Section 18(2) of RTI Act.	01	02
2	Number of Complaints where the inquiry initiated by the Commission was completed.	01	02
3	Please indicate whether the inquiry reports are uploaded on the website of the Commission for the said period.	Nil.	Nil.
4	Please provide copies of the inquiry reports on Complaints for the said period where inquiry has been concluded.	8	16
		TOTAL :	Rs.20/-

It is requested that the above fees of Rs.20/- (Rupees Twenty only) be paid by way of sticking revenue stamp worth Rs.20/- on a paper addressed to this office.

{ Siddhi T. Halarnakar)

Under Secretary / PIO,

Goa State Information Commission.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

RTI. No.GSIC/US/PIO/RTI/2014/

Office of State Information Commission,

Shrama Shakti Bhavan,

Ground Floor, Panaji, Goa.

Dated : 19/05/2014.

Contact : 2437208.

To,

Mrs. Anjali Bharadwaj,

R/o. B-76, S.F.S Flats (Triveni Apartments),

Sheikh Sarai Phase-I, New Delhi. 110017.

Contact : 011-41018185.

Subject : Information under Right to Information Act, 2005.

With reference to your RTI application dated 28/04/2014 (Inward/Entry dated 02/05/2014) on the subject cited above, I am to inform you that the information sought by you is as follows :

Sr. No.	Question.	Reply.
1.	Number of Complaints where an inquiry was initiated by the Commission as per the powers vested in it under Section 18(2) of RTI Act.	Annexure ‘A’.
2	Number of Complaints where the inquiry initiated by the Commission was completed.	Annexure ‘B’.
3	Please indicate whether the inquiry reports are uploaded on the wedsite of the Commission for the said period.	Yes.
4	Please provide copies of the inquiry reports on Complaints for the said period where inquiry has been concluded.	Enclosed copies of the inquiry reports on Complaints for the period 2012 to 2013 where inquiry has been concluded (8 pages).

{ Siddhi T. Halarnakar)

Under Secretary / PIO,

Goa State Information Commission.

Encl : Annexures A, B, and C.

Annexure ‘A’

Question No.1.

Information required.	January-December, 2012.	January-December, 2013.
Number of Complaints where an inquiry was initiated by the Commissionas per the powers vested in it under Section 18(2) of RTI Act.	03	00

Annexure ‘B’

Question No.2.

Information required.	January-December, 2012.	January-December, 2013.
Number of Complaints where the inquiry initiated by the Commission was completed.	03	00

RTI. No.GSIC/US/PIO/RTI/2014/

Office of State Information Commission,

Shrama Shakti Bhavan,

Ground Floor, Panaji, Goa.

Dated : 08/05/2014.

Contact : 2437208.

To,

Shri. C. S. Barreto,

R/o. H.No.206, Mazalvaddo,

Assagao, Bardez, Goa.

Subject : Information under Right to Information Act, 2005.

With reference to your RTI application dated 20/01/2014 on the subject cited above, I am to inform you that the PIO/Information Officer, Department of Information and Publicity vide letter No.DI/RTI/Reply/2014/193, dated 06/05/2014 (Inward/Entry dated 07/05/2014) transferred your RTI application to this office of PIO under section 6(3) of RTI Act, 2005.

The nature of information sought by you in your said application is in the form of clarification which in turn amounts to an opinion and hence the same does not come within the definition of ‘information” under the RTI, Act, 2005 and hence cannot be given.

{ Siddhi T. Halarnakar)

Under Secretary / PIO,

Goa State Information Commission.

--------------------------------------

RTI. No.GSIC/US/PIO/RTI/2014/

Office of State Information Commission,

Shrama Shakti Bhavan,

Ground Floor, Panaji, Goa.

Dated : 07/05/2014.

Contact : 2437208.

To,

Shri. Hanumant Babuli Redkar,

R/o. Housing Board Colony, Camurlim, Bardez, Goa.

Subject : Information under Right to Information Act, 2005.

With reference to your RTI application dated 29/01/2014 (Inward/Entry dated 30/01/2014) on the subject cited above, I am to inform you that the information sought by you is as follows :

Sr. No.	Question.	Reply.
1.	Please furnish certify copies of information relating to attendance register of the staff/Officers of Goa State Infrmation Commission for the period from October, 2013 to December, 2013.	Annexure ‘A’ (1 to 6).
2	Please furnish certify copy of details of pattern of Assistance granted to Goa State Information Commission in the year 2012.	Annexure ‘B’.
3	Certify copy of information relating to amount of payments made to three master Peons engaged by the Hon. Chief Information Commissioner with details of their name, address, and photo identity and Xerox copy acknowledgement of payment by the master Peon.	Information relating to amount of payments made to three master Peons for the months of October, November, and December of year 2013 and Xerox copy of acknowledgement of payment by the master Peons is given in Annexures C (1 to 8) As regards the information of the details of their address and photo identity is concerned, the same amounts to third party information and the said three master Peons have refused to allow this PIO to give the said third party information.

Contd …… 2/-

- 2 -

4	Total No. of cases( appeal and complaints ) received and disposed by the State Information Commission wef October, 2013 to December,2013.	Annexure ‘D’.
5	Total no. of cases as on 31/12/2013 pending in the commission ie Appeals and Complaints	Annexure ‘E’.

{ Siddhi T. Halarnakar)

Under Secretary / PIO,

Goa State Information Commission.

Encl : Annexures.

ANNEXURE ‘D’

Question No.4 : Total number of Appeal and Complaint cases received and disposed during the

period October,2013 to December,2013 by the State Information Commission.

Month and year.	Total number of Appeal cases :		Total number of Complaints cases :
	Received.	Disposed.	Received.	Disposed.
October,2013.	15	0	12	0
November,2013.	12	2	12	4
Dccember,2013.	11	3	4	0
TOTAL :	38	5	28	4

ANNEXURE ‘E’

Question No.5 : Total number of Appeal and Complaint cases pending as on 31/12/2013 in the

State Information Commission.

Total number of Appeal cases pending as on 31/12/2013.	Total number of Complaint cases pending as on 31/12/2013.
595	541

RTI. No.GSIC/US/PIO/RTI/2014/

Office of State Information Commission,

Shrama Shakti Bhavan,

Ground Floor, Panaji, Goa.

Dated : 07/05/2014.

Contact : 2437208.

To,

Mrs. Anjali Bharadwaj,

R/o. B-76, S.F.S Flats (Triveni Apartments),

Sheikh Sarai Phase-I, New Delhi. 110017.

Contact : 011-41018185.

Subject : Information under Right to Information Act, 2005.

Sr. No.	Question.	Number of pages.	Amount of fees ( in rupees).
1.	Number of Complaints where an inquiry was initiated by the Commission as per the powers vested in it under Section 18(2) of RTI Act.	01	02
2	Number of Complaints where the inquiry initiated by the Commission was completed.	01	02
3	Please indicate whether the inquiry reports are uploaded on the website of the Commission for the said period.	Nil.	Nil.
4	Please provide copies of the inquiry reports on Complaints for the said period where inquiry has been concluded.	8	16

{ Siddhi T. Halarnakar)

Under Secretary / PIO,

Goa State Information Commission.

RTI. No.GSIC/US/PIO/RTI/2014/

Office of State Information Commission,

Shrama Shakti Bhavan,

Ground Floor, Panaji, Goa.

Dated : 07/05/2014.

Contact : 2437208.

To,

Mrs. Anjali Bharadwaj,

R/o. B-76, S.F.S Flats (Triveni Apartments),

Sheikh Sarai Phase-I, New Delhi. 110017.

Contact : 011-41018185.

Subject : Information under Right to Information Act, 2005.

With reference to your RTI application dated 28/04/2014 (Inward/Entry dated 02/05/2014) on the subject cited above, I am to inform you that the information sought by you is as follows :

Sr. No.	Question.	Reply.
1.	Number of Complaints where an inquiry was initiated by the Commissionas per the powers vested in it under Section 18(2) of RTI Act.	Annexure ‘A’.
2	Number of Complaints where the inquiry initiated by the Commission was completed.	Annexure ‘B’.
3	Please indicate whether the inquiry reports are uploaded on the wedsite of the Commission for the said period.	Annexure ‘C’.
4	Please provide copies of the inquiry reports on Complaints for the said period where inquiry has been concluded.	Annexure ‘D’.

{ Siddhi T. Halarnakar)

Under Secretary / PIO,

Goa State Information Commission.

Encl : Annexures.

RTI. No.GSIC/US/PIO/RTI/2014/

Office of State Information Commission,

Shrama Shakti Bhavan,

Ground Floor, Panaji, Goa.

Dated : 23/04/2014.

Contact : 2437208.

To,

Shri. Jawaharlal. T. Shetye,

R/o. H.No.35, Mapusa Jana Jagruti Samiti, Ward No.11,

Khorlim, Mapusa, Goa.

Subject : Information under Right to Information Act, 2005.

With reference to your RTI application dated 21/01/2014 on the subject cited above, I am to inform you that the PIO/Deputy Director (Administration), Directorate of Municipal Administration vide letter No.10/629/2014-DMA/RTI/3267, dated 31/01/2014 (Inward/Entry dated 03/02/2014) transferred the point No.5 of your RTI application to this office of PIO under section 6(3) of RTI Act, 2005.

Point No.	Question.	Reply.
5.	Furnish me the list of pending RTI appeals and complaints against Mapusa Municipal Council before the Goa State Information Commission filed by various applicants/complainants. Out of which how many cases pertains for non compliance of orders of the First Appellate Authority and where Mr. Hanumant Toraskar is the Public Information Officer.	The list of pending RTI appeals and complaints against the Mapusa Municipal Council is available in the Register of Cases maintained in the office of the GSIC. The copies of the extract of the said Register will be provided to you on any working day and time. As regards the number of cases against the Mapusa Municipal council for non compliance of order of FAA and where PIO was one Mr. Hanumant Toraskar, you are allowed to inspect the case files (appeals and complaints) pertaining to the Mapusa Municipal Council, and copies which you require will be provided.

{ Siddhi T. Halarnakar)

Under Secretary / PIO,

Goa State Information Commission.

RTI. No.GSIC/US/PIO/RTI/2014/

Office of State Information Commission,

Shrama Shakti Bhavan,

Ground Floor, Panaji, Goa.

Dated : 23/04/2014.

Contact : 0832-2437208.

To,

Smt. Brigida Carneiro, and

Miss. Fatima Carneiro,

Both R/o. H.No.872, Mandopa, Navelim,

Salcete, Goa. 403707.

Contact : 9767827943 / 9763548150.

Subject : Application to inquire into the delay to release information under

RTI Act, 2005.

Reference : First Appeal dated 18/03/2014 (Inward/Entry dated 19/03/2014)

filed by Smt. Brigida Carneiro, and Miss. Fatima Carneiro, r/o.

Navelim, Salcete, Goa.

With reference to your first appeal dated 18/03/2014 (Inward/Entry dated 19/03/2014) addressed to the Secretary / First Appellate Authority, State Information Commission, I am to inform you that the said appeal is wrongly filed before the Secretary of the State Information Commission as the Secretary, GSIC is not the First Appellate Authority in case of Department of Education.

The said appeal is returned and enclosed herewith in order to file before the Director, Department of Education ( Contact No.2416023 and 2416139 ) who is the First Appellate Authority in case of Department of Education.

{ Siddhi T. Halarnakar)

Under Secretary / PIO,

Goa State Information Commission.

Encl : As above.

RTI. No.GSIC/US/PIO/RTI/2014/

Office of State Information Commission,

Shrama Shakti Bhavan,

Ground Floor, Panaji, Goa.

Dated : 23/04/2014.

Contact : 0832-2437208.

To,

Shri. Narainrao Santobarao Desai,

602, Kamat Towers, Patto Plaza, Patto,

Panaji, Goa.

Contact : 0832-2437107 / 9422417039.

Subject : First Appeal under RTI Act,2005 ….. regarding.

Reference : First Appeal dated 18/02/2014 (Inward/Entry dated 20/02/2014)

filed by Shri. Narainrao Santobarao Desai, r/o. Panaji, Goa.

With reference to your first appeal dated 18/02/2014 (Inward/Entry dated 20/02/2014) addressed to the Secretary / First Appellate Authority, State Information Commission, I am to inform you that the said appeal is wrongly filed before the Secretary of the State Information Commission as the Secretary, GSIC is not the First Appellate Authority in case of Sports Authority of Goa.

The said appeal is returned and enclosed herewith in order to file before the Executive Director, Sports Authority of Goa ( Contact No.2438099) who is the First Appellate Authority in case of Sports Authority of Goa.

{ Siddhi T. Halarnakar)

Under Secretary / PIO,

Goa State Information Commission.

Encl : As above.

RTI. No.GSIC/US/PIO/RTI/2014/

Office of State Information Commission,

Shrama Shakti Bhavan,

Ground Floor, Panaji, Goa.

Dated : 23/04/2014.

Contact : 0832-2437208.

To,

Public Information Officer / Assistant Director(Marathi),

Directorate of Official Language,

First Lift, 5^th Floor, Junta House, Panaji, Goa.

Contact : 0832-2420071 / 0832-2420179.

Subject : Transfer of Application under section 6(3) of the RTI Act, 2005.

Reference : RTI application dated 30/03/2014 ( Inward / Entry dated

16/04/2014) of Shri. Satyendra Singh, r/o. Pune, Maharashtra.

With reference to the above cited RTI letter dated 30/03/2014 ( Inward / Entry dated 16/04/2014) of Shri. Satyendra Singh, I am enclosing herewith and transferring the same under section 6(3) of the RTI Act, 2005 to your office for necessary action and to provide the information to the applicant, as the information sought by the applicant pertains to your office.

{ Siddhi T. Halarnakar)

Under Secretary / PIO,

Goa State Information Commission.

Encl : As above.

Copy To : Shri. Satyendra Singh, r/o. B. No.2263, Rameshwari Sadan, Saptagiri

Co-operative Housing Society Ltd(redg), survey No.51/1, Plot No.44,

Jambhulwadi road, Ambegaon Khurd, Pune, Maharashtra, 411046.

RTI. No.GSIC/US/PIO/RTI/2014/

Office of State Information Commission,

Shrama Shakti Bhavan,

Ground Floor, Panaji, Goa.

Dated : 23/04/2014.

Contact : 2437208.

To,

Public Information Officer / Superintendent of Police,

CID, Crime Branch,

Donapaula, Goa.

Contact : 2456688.

Subject : Transfer of Application under section 6(3) of the RTI Act, 2005.

Reference : RTI application dated 26/03/2014 ( Inward / Entry dated

07/04/2014) of Shri. Sandeep Mohan Padwalkar, r/o.

Zuarinagar, Vasco, Goa., Contact No. 9423323183/9765255457.

With reference to the above cited RTI letter dated 26/03/2014 ( Inward / Entry dated 07/04/2014) of Shri. Sandeep Mohan Padwalkar, I am enclosing herewith and transferring the same under section 6(3) of the RTI Act, 2005 to your office for necessary action and to provide the information to the applicant, as the information sought by the applicant pertains to your office.

{ Siddhi T. Halarnakar)

Under Secretary / PIO,

Goa State Information Commission.

Encl : As above.

Copy To : Shri. Sandeep Mohan Padwalkar, r/o. B-G-4, Housing Board Colony,

Upasnagar, Zuarinagar, Vasco, Goa., Contact No. 9423323183 /

9765255457.

RTI. No.GSIC/US/PIO/RTI/2014/

Office of State Information Commission,

Shrama Shakti Bhavan,

Ground Floor, Panaji, Goa.

Dated : 23/04/2014.

Contact : 2437208.

To,

Shri. Narayan Deu Gauns,

H.No.536, Bazarwada, Marcela, Goa.

Contact : 9850780179.

Subject : No response from Tivrem Orgao Panchayat, Marcela, Goa.

Reference : RTI application dated 16/04/2014 ( Inward / Entry dated

17/04/2014) of Shri. Narayan Deu Gauns, r/o. Marcela, Goa.

With reference to your RTI letter dated 16^th April,2014 ( Inward / Entry dated 17/04/2014) on the subject cited above, I am to inform you that the information sought by you is not available with this office.

Sr. No.	Question.	Reply.
1.	Why didn’t the Panchayat respond to our letter ?	Information not available with this office.

The applicant can seek information from the Public Information Officer (PIO) of the Village Panchayat of Tivrem Orgao, Marcela, Goa by making a separate application under RTI to the PIO of VP of Tivrem Orgao.

{ Siddhi T. Halarnakar)

Under Secretary / PIO,

Goa State Information Commission.

----------------------------------------

----------

MY RTI JUDGEMENTS

Thursday, September 22, 2016

Some RTI info